Dear Mr. Sadek:
I am writing a sympathetic article about the Innocence of Muslims movie from a different angle than the ones I've seen in the media.
“Disgusting and Reprehensible” said Hillary Clinton when referring to the YouTube clip “Innocence of Muslims” “We absolutely reject it’s content and message” she said hoping that her words would calm the raging Muslim world. It is “a crude and disgusting video” Obama told the United Nations and “the future must not belong to those who slander the prophet of Islam”. “Innocence of Muslims is a stupid hate film” wrote numerous bloggers. Nakoula the author of the movie now sits in jail. In countries all over the Muslim world there have been riots protesting Nakoula’s movie. Pakistani Government minister Ghulam Ahmad Bilour put a $100,000 bounty on Nakoula’s head. An Egyptian Muslim cleric has called on American Muslim youth to kill Nakoula, and everyone involved in the video, including actors, actresses and anyone who has promoted Innocence of Muslims. Americans Muslims have threatened to chop off Nakoula’s head. Richard Gere , told journalists he was open to shooting any movie that helped present Muslims in a more positive light.
This movie is hard to get hold of but it’s trailer is still available on YouTube despite pressure from the Obama administration on google to remove it.
The trailer starts with a constable telling a doctor “our prophet had 61 wives and 11 at the same time.” According to Islamic texts Muhammad did have many wives.
The clip continues with the Doctor telling his daughter to close the clinic because of an angry mob on the street. A Muslim says to burn the place and a woman is killed by a member of the mob.
Muslim mobs have attacked Christians throughout the Middle East but have they attacked medical clinics? A good place to find the answer is the religion of peace web site. The most recent example of an attack on a hospital prior to October 4, 2012 (the date this article was written) took place in Iraq on January 15, 2011. The most recent attack on a Christian doctor by Muslims took place on July 26, 2012 in Egypt. The doctor was blinded because he asked Muslims to stop firing weapons up in the air in celebration. What about the murder of a Christian woman in the movie? The most recent murder of a Christian woman by Muslims was on September 23, 2012 in Nigeria.
In the movie trailer the police arrive and the master sergeant says “Freeze do not take any action until everything is over.”
Lack of intervention by Muslim police when Christians are attacked is well known.
In the next scene the doctor tells his daughter “The Islamic Egyptian Police arrested 1,400 Christians, tortured them and forced them to confess to killings”.
There have been numerous incidents across the Arab world where police have arrested Christians for infractions such as insulting Islam though often the role of police is to stay away while Arab mobs attack the Christians. In one incident On 31 May 2008, monks and Christians close to the Coptic Monastery of the Saint Fana reported that monks' cells and a church belonging to the monastery had been attacked by a group of roughly sixty armed Arabs.
A subsequent attack left one Muslim killed, four Christians wounded, and three monks being briefly kidnapped, requiring hospital treatment upon their return. (Al-Misri al-Yawm of 1, 2, 3 and 8 July 2008 , al-Usbua of 7 June 2008, al-Dustur of 2 July 2008 (Egyptian newspapers )The reason the three kidnapped monks required medical treatment was because they were tortured by the Arabs, The clashes were followed one day later by a demonstration of around 300 Coptic youth in Mallawi who blamed the government for "inaction in the face of repeated attacks by Muslims against their community."
Monks of the monastery criticized local police, stationed approximately 6 km from the monastery, for arriving at the monastery several hours after having been informed of the attack.
Not only do Egyptian police not protect the Copts the Egyptian military attacks the Copts. Activists marched to the state-run TV station in Cairo, chanting and demanding reforms. Instead of protection, however, the military regime responded with brute force. “Security” forces mowed down hundreds of Christian protesters with guns and tanks, killing dozens and injuring hundreds more.
Hundreds of thousands of Copts have already been forced to flee their homes. Was it reprehensible of Nakoura to point out the plight of the Copts in his movie?
In the next scene in the trailer two men discuss hiding the disgrace that Muhammad was born of an unknown father.
Muslims believe the father of Muhammad was Abdallah but Muhammad was the wrong age to have been Abdallah’s son since Muhammad was 2 and his father had died six years previously. This age discrepancy is from several Islamic sources.
In another scene in the movie Muhammad’s wife Khadijah orders him to sit on her lap.
According to Ibn Ishaq’s book, The Life of Muhammad Kadijah did a test to see if the spirit who came to Muhammad was an angel or the devil. According to Ibn Ishaq the author of Sirat Rusal Allah the biography of Muhammad, she told Muhammad to sit on her lap and then disclosed her form and asked if Muhammad could still see the spirit. When he said no she said that the spirit must be an angel and not the devil.
In the next episode in the movie Hadijah’s cousin says he will help Muhammad. He says “ I will make a book for him. It will be mix between some versions of – from the Torah and some versions from the New Testament and mix them into false verses.” The cousin dies and Muhammad is upset because he’s lost his inspiration.
The Koran makes reference to Christian and Jewish doctrine. Biblical scholar Dr. Robert M. Price wrote:
"The Koran was assembled from a variety of prior Hagarene texts … in order to provide the Moses-like Muhammad with a Torah of his own...."
Islamic expert Dr. Gerd-R. Puin similarly concludes:
"My idea is that the Koran is a kind of cocktail of texts that were not all understood even at the time of Muhammad. Many of them may even be a hundred years older than Islam itself. Even within Islamic traditions there is a huge body of contradictory information, including a significant Christian substrate...."
Islamic texts even quote al-Nadr a person who did not believe in Islam as saying regarding Muhammad “ He is spouting ancient legends that he has gathered from the mouths of men more learned than he."
The author or authors of the Koran must have learned those doctrines somewhere. The movie suggests that Khadija ‘s cousin Waraqa bin Naufil may have been the learned source of Islamic doctrine. Waraqa had been converted to Christianity in the Pre-lslamic Period and used to write about the Gospel in Arabic. According to Islamic texts when Waraqa died the Divine Inspiration was paused (stopped) for a while so that Allah's Apostle was very much grieved. Nakoula calls the advisor to Muhammad “the master” in the movie.
In the next scene the master tells Muhammad that in the next raid to kill the men and capture the women, loot and sell the children.
Islamic text support all of this. According to the Koran Muhammad started his military career by launching raids against the Quraysh and looting their caravans. Two months after his first successful raid Muhammad led over 300 men against a large Meccan caravan which was making its way home from Syria.
Muhammad told his followers:
"It is likely that Allah may give it to you as booty." (Ibn Sa'd, Vol. II, 9.)
Notice that he made it's God will to attack and steal and kill. In the next scene the master tells a married woman to wait for him in her tent. A girl asks “Isn’t it shameful for a woman to expose herself to a man she does not know?” and the master answers that “Have you not heard what God has said in the Quran. The Master may desire whom he wants and shall be given whom he wants.”
According to the Koran (33:50), Allah made it legitimate for Muhammad to have sex with any woman who “offered” herself to him/ Muhammad permitted all the infidel woman that they could capture, as concubines (Koran 4:3).
According to (Sahih Bukhari 5.236) when Muhamamd was 51 years old he married a six year old child, a marriage he consummated when she was 9 years old. Muhammad explained that God wanted him to do so:
"...the Prophet said to her (Aisha), 'You have been shown to me twice in my dream. I saw you pictured on a piece of silk and someone said (to me). 'This is your wife.' When I uncovered the picture, I saw that it was yours. I said, 'If this is from Allah, it will be done.'"
According to the Muslim historian Abu Ja'far Muhammad bin Jarir al-Tabari (839-923), one of Muhammad's many sons, Zayad married a beautiful wife by the name of Zainab and Muhammad wanted her. One day Muhammad was talking with Aisha (one of his wives) when "a fainting overcame him." Then he smiled and asked, "Who will go to Zaynab to tell her the good news, saying that God has married her to me?" He then recited the revelation Allah had just given him, scolding him for being concerned about what people might think and thus refusing to marry Zaynab. (Qur'an 33:37)In the next scene in the movie an elderly woman says:
My age has exceeded 120 years and in all my young life ‘I haven’t seen such a murderous thug as Muhammad’. He kills men, captures women and children, robs the caravans, breaches agreements and treaties. He sells the children as slaves after he and his men have used them. And what’s more, he does this all in the name of God. What God is this? That he’s such an oppressor and so unfair to the people.
Perhaps the most famous example of Muhammad engaging in the behavior described by the woman in the movie was his actions toward the Jewish tribe of the Bani Quraysa. He accused the Jewish tribe of the Bani Quraysa of wanting to betray him and had a convenient communication from the angel Gabriel who ordered him to attack them. He went to them, put them under siege for 14 days. Finally they surrendered. So Mohammed killed all their men, enslaved their women and children [Saheeh Muslim - 1769]. Ibn Ishaq gave the details:
The apostle went out to the market of Medina and dug trenches in it. Then he sent for the men of Qurayzah and struck off their heads as they were brought out to him in batches until 600 to 700 of them were dead.
The Jewish women and children were enslaved and Muhammad took one of them, a fifteen year old girl named Rayhana bint Zayd ibn Amr as a personal slave.In the movie, the elderly woman, is torn apart by camels tied to opposite ends of her body after saying this.
This scene is based on the murder of Umm Qirfah a leader of the Fazarah tribe. According to Tabari Vol.8:Page.96
Allah’s Messenger sent Zayd to Wadi Qura, where he encountered the Banu Fazarah. Some of his companions were killed, and Zayd was carried away wounded. … After he recovered, Muhammad sent him with an army against the Fazarah settlement. He met them in Qura and inflicted casualties on them and took Umm Qirfah prisoner. .. Zyad bin Harithah ordered Qays to kill Umm, and he killed her cruelly. He tied each of her legs with a rope and tied the ropes to two camels, and they split her in two.In the next scene we hear:
Let us take the other treasure. Cut off his arms and his legs and then his head and do it in front of his beautiful wife Sophia.
(laughs) As you command Master.
This is probably based on the story of Safiyya a 17 year old girl of "incomparable beauty" (Ibn Saad, al-Tabaqat, pp. 120-123) whose husband Kinana knew where the treasure of his tribe was hidden. In order to get Kinana to reveal where the treasure was the Muslims lit a fire on his chest but Kinana died refusing to reveal it’s location. Muhammad killed Safiyya’s father himself along with the Jewish men of Qurayza. Muhammad forced Safiyya to be one of his wives and raped her.The inescapable conclusion of this analysis of the movie is that it closely resembles events described in Islamic texts. If one says as Secretary of State Clinton did, that it is a disgusting and reprehensible movie one is really saying that Islam is a disgusting and reprehensible religion.